By Barbara Lavender, Attorney at Law
From: Ask a Lawyer section of the Boulder Daily Camera
Q: The problems between my spouse and me that caused our marriage to end might make divorce mediation an impractical forum for us. If attorneys are involved, how can we still minimize the financial and emotional costs of the divorce?
A: If not all issues can be resolved through mediation, because
of ineffective communication and/or great differences in opinion,
working through attorneys can still be approached in a manner consistent
with integrity and fairness.
It is not necessary or effective to take a battleground perspective
in order to achieve a fair result that protects your interests.
Express to your spouse your intention to resolve the disputes with
as little bitterness and blame as possible. Then choose an attorney
who will support you intention to obtain results that are fair and
in the best interests of your children and who will foster the process
of divorce as the beginning of a new period, as well as the ending
of the marriage.
Once aligned in that intention, if advised that your proposed strategy
will only increase your legal fees and maintain a status of "dirty
fighting," and that there is nothing to be gained through such
action, be willing to return to your basic strategy of obtaining
fairness with integrity.
Before getting caught up in the process of dueling positions, prepare for the divorce process by examining certain questions and writing out your basic concepts of fairness. If there are children involved, ask yourself how decisions regarding the children have been made during the marriage, how much and how effectively you and your spouse have participated in making those decisions, whether that method has resulted in decisions consistent with the children's interests, whether a different method would work better and, if so, why. Later, when proposals for child custody are being asserted and considered, evaluate the alternatives from the perspective of this initial personal evaluation of the children's welfare.
Further, ask yourself which parent has been primarily responsible for the child
care--taking the children to events and appointments, feeding and
dressing them, etc. Do the children seem comfortable with the established
situation? Refer to this information in deciding which parent the
children should live with primarily (the primary residential custodian),
in order to sustain a primary relationship that works for them.
If you believe the children have not benefitted from the established
pattern of caretaking, state your reasons clearly for your attorney
so that they can advise regarding the relevance to the children's
welfare.
Consider what pattern of visitation would allow the parent with whom the children are not living primarily to maintain (or develop) a quality relationship with the children. Then ask your attorney for advice regarding visitation arrangements recommended by a mental health professional for children.
If there is a marital home, consider whether the children need the stability of the familiar residence, school and neighborhood friends. If so, consider whether it is possible and reasonable for the primary residential custodian to continue to reside there. If there is a marital home but no children, write out why you believe you should stay in the home, and why you believe your spouse feels he or she is entitled to stay there.
Apply the same approach to the questions of division of marital
property and maintenance (alimony): consider what you believe to
be fair, and why. Your attorney may choose not to read your statement,
but as you receive legal advice, use it as a reference standard.
Be prepared to abandon beliefs that you are advised are completely
inappropriate to legal considerations. For example, Colorado is
a "no fault" divorce jurisdiction, and positions based
on incidents that offend your moral values will probably not be
considered in determining a fair settlement. If you have trouble
accepting the conclusion that your beliefs cannot be supported by
law, avoid the temptation to spend expensive time arguing with your
attorney. Instead, either seek a second opinion, or work through
your frustrations with a counselor.
Even where your interests can be considered, not all of them will
be strictly relevant to the legal issues. However, if your desires
and beliefs about fairness remain unspoken, you will arrive at an
outcome unrelated to your interests, without knowing why.
This results in a sense of helplessness, which prevents effective
movement into a new life after the divorce. In addition, by clearly
presenting your perspective, you can obtain a successful settlement
that is consistent with the law, but addresses your specific goals.
In one case, a client felt strongly that it was fair to give her
spouse "credit" for actions that would not be considered
in the legal context. When her belief was communicated, her spouse
reciprocated by offering a generous division of property, while
he had previously been very resistant to a fair sharing. Their settlement
fit the needs and abilities of both parties and was achieved with
a minimum of expense and rancor.
When you do mediate, choose mediators who are capable of obtaining
true agreement that reflects the interests of both spouses, by eliciting
and validating the interests of the less assertive spouse. A mediator
skilled in these techniques can also help establish communication,
which is necessary if the parties will continue co-parenting their
children in the future.
My practice includes the full range of family law services, including prenuptial and antenuptial agreements, all aspects of divorce, allocation of parental responsibilities (formerly known as custody), step-parent adoptions, grandparent rights, and estate planning. I also provide family law and estate planning services to gays and lesbians, including parental rights (for couples residing anywhere in Colorado), allocation of parental rights, sperm donor agreements, surrogacy agreements, gay and lesbian "divorce," domestic partnership agreements, wills, trusts, and powers of attorney.